South Dakota’s Thune to forgo presidential run

John Thune.U.S. Sen. John Thune, R-S.D., leapt onto the national scene back in 2004 when he defeated then-Senate minority leader Tom Daschle.

That victory got many Republicans across the country thinking about Thune’s future, so it was only natural that when Republicans began talking about who might be able to topple a sitting Democratic president in 2012, Thune was on the short list.

Thune, a Murdo native, explored the idea of running for president in 2012 but announced this week that he’s not going to do it.

"I feel that I am best positioned to fight for America’s future here in the trenches of the United States Senate," read a statement he issued on his website.

I translate that to mean Thune didn’t think he had a great chance of winning. If you’re a politician and you think you have a great chance of winning the presidency, you run. The only reason you wouldn’t run — other than skeletons in the closet, which most people doubt Thune has — is if you don’t feel you have a great chance of getting your party’s nomination or winning the general election.

Thune’s decision was probably made easier by the fact that he’s a young 50, and he could certainly still run in 2016 or beyond. The wide-open Republican field for 2012 is sure to be a slugfest, and the victor will have to challenge one of the great politicians of our time in Barack Obama. That’s a tough set of circumstances.

In 2016, the timing might be better for Thune. At the moment (and assuming Obama wins a second term), it’s unlikely there will be a vice president from the outgoing administration in the 2016 race, which could make for an entirely different and relatively easier campaign.

For now, Thune joins the short list of South Dakota politicians who’ve seriously considered but stopped short of running for president. They include his former opponent, Tom Daschle, as well as former Sens. Karl Mundt and Larry Pressler (both Republicans). And then there was South Dakota native Hubert Humphrey, the former senator from Minnesota who was a Democratic presidential candidate many times.

The only South Dakotan to win a major-party presidential nomination is George McGovern, the Democrat who lost the 1972 general election to Richard Nixon.

Categories: Commentary, General News

About Author

Seth Tupper

Seth Tupper was born and raised in South Dakota and earned a bachelor's degree in journalism from South Dakota State University in 2001. After college, he worked at a newspaper in Minnesota and then returned to South Dakota in 2003 to join the staff of The Daily Republic in Mitchell, where he is currently the publisher. Seth has won numerous awards for his writing, including the 2007 Outstanding Young Journalist award in the daily newspapers category of the South Dakota Newspaper Association's Better Newspapers Contest. Seth's day-job and freelance work have granted him opportunities to meet hundreds of South Dakotans and travel across much of the state. He also spends a lot of his free time exploring South Dakota's state and national parks, hiking trails and kayak-friendly rivers.


  1. Jennifer
    Jennifer 21 June, 2011, 18:31

    Really bummed about this. I think he would make a great president. I bet by the following election we’ll be seeing his name on the the ticket though.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply